History’s Top Brain Computation Insights: Day 2

This post is part of a series chronicling history's top brain computation insights (see the first of the series for a detailed description).

2)  Brain signals are electrical (Galvani – 1791, Rolando – 1809)

Galvani (whose name inspired the word 'galvanize') discovered that electrically shocking frog nerves made their muscles move. Rolando used this same method to stimulate cortex in the brain.

As has often occurred in history, the latest and most mysterious new technology was used to explain brain function. Here, at the turn of the 19th century the brain was "explained" as a mysterious electrical device. Later it will be "explained" as a telegraph with its many communicators (neurons) and wires (axons). Then it was described as a telephone network, with switchboards acting to control the flow of information. Eventually, with the cognitive revolution, it was compared to a computer. Finally, today, its complex and distributed network architecture is compared to the internet.

Though each new comparison is always premature and inadequate, new insights nonetheless seem to derive from each analogy. What new technology of tomorrow will be used to describe brain function?

Implication: The mind is implemented in an electrical machine-like organ.

-MC 

2 thoughts on “History’s Top Brain Computation Insights: Day 2

  1. This was a really fascinating insight when compared to the earlier ideas of the brain as a system which distills and evaporates the "spirits" (e.g. Willis in the 1600s). Later, in the late 1700s, Haller brought up that some people thought of the brain as electrical, but he argued that elecrtical currents would not remain confined to the nerves:

    "But concerning the nature of this nervous liquid, there are many doubts. Many of the moderns will have it to be extremely elastic, of an etherial or of an electrical matter […]. An electrical matter is, indeed, very powerful, and fit for motion; but then it is not confinable within the nerves since it penetrates throughout the whoe animal to which it is communicated…. but […] this liquid must be of a nature that will make it flow through and be contained within the small pipes of the nerves. And a ligature on the nerve takes away sense and motion, but cannot stop the motion of a torrent of electrical matter."

    One does have to wonder how much the metaphors we use to understand brain function are coupled to contemporary technologies (e.g. electricity, Internet). =)

    -PL

  2. “Galvanize” is no big whup, homage-wise. Electricity itself was once “galvanism,” and the term is alive in use for battery-driven current.

Leave a Comment